Grade Your Vinyl. Then See Where Others Disagree.

A structured reference for grading records using Goldmine criteria. Answer a few honest questions, get your grade, and learn exactly where buyers push back most.

Start Grading

Goldmine Grade Comparison

How each grade maps to what you should actually hear and see. This table is the reference most experienced sellers use when they disagree with a listing.

Grade	Abbreviation	What It Means	Common Dispute
Mint	M	Perfect. Never played, sealed or as close to perfect as possible.	Almost nobody honestly grades a played record as M. If it's been on a turntable, it's at best NM.
Near Mint	NM or M-	Appears unplayed. No visible defects. May have been played once or twice. The highest grade for any record that has left its sleeve.	The most abused grade in vinyl sales. Many sellers call a record NM when it's really VG+. True NM should have zero audible flaws on a decent system.
Very Good Plus	VG+	Shows slight signs of wear. Light scuffs or scratches that do not affect play. May have faint surface noise between tracks.	This is the most disputed grade anywhere. Sellers call VG+ what buyers think is VG. If you hear any noise during the music, it's probably VG at best.
Very Good	VG	Visible wear and light scratches. Surface noise audible but not overwhelming. No skips.	Some sellers treat VG as a catch-all. A true VG record has obvious wear but still plays through without skipping.
Good Plus	G+	Significant wear. Surface noise present throughout. Scratches visible but no skips on most players.	Often confused with VG. If the noise is distracting during normal listening, it's G+ or lower.
Good	G	Heavy wear. Plays through but with considerable noise. Not pleasant to listen to for most collectors.	Records at this grade are usually only valuable for rare titles. Buyers expect honesty about specific flaws.
Poor	P	Barely playable. Severe damage, skips, or unlistening-level noise.	Only worth listing if extremely rare. Full disclosure of every flaw is essential.

Common Overgrading Patterns

These are the mistakes sellers make most often. Check your own grading against these patterns before you list.

The "Plays Perfectly" Trap

A seller says a record "plays perfectly" but grades it VG+. If it truly played perfectly, it would be NM. The language and the grade don't match. Always grade based on what you hear on a good system, not a worn-out turntable with a heavy stylus.

Ignoring Between-Track Noise

Some sellers only grade based on noise during loud passages. Goldmine grading considers noise at any point. If you hear ticks or crackle between tracks, the grade drops. Quiet passages and run-out grooves count.

Confusing Visual and Audio Grade

A record can look terrible but sound great (pressing marks that don't affect play). Or it can look fine but have groove wear from a bad stylus. The audio grade always wins. But mention visual flaws in your listing text.

The Sleeve Discount

Sellers often grade the media correctly but ignore the sleeve. A NM record in a VG sleeve is not a NM sale. Buyers care about the whole package. Always grade media and sleeve separately and mention both.

Sticker and Writing Blindness

Many sellers forget to mention stickers, writing, or drill holes on the label or sleeve. These are defects. A price sticker on the label knocks a record down at least one grade level for most buyers.

Batch Bias

When grading a whole collection, sellers tend to grade everything relative to what they have. If your worst records are G, a VG record starts to feel like NM. Grade each record on its own merits against the standard.

Marketplace-Specific Grading Notes

Different platforms have different expectations. Here is what to know where.

Discogs

Discogs uses the Goldmine Standard directly. Buyers expect strict grading here. VG+ on Discogs should mean actual VG+. Overgrading leads to returns and bad feedback. Use the "Notes" field for every specific defect, even at NM.

eBay

eBay buyers are more varied. Casual buyers may not know the difference between VG and VG+. Be extra specific in your descriptions. Include phrases like "light surface noise between tracks" rather than just the grade.

Record Fairs & Shops

In person, buyers can inspect the record. Grading tends to be more generous because buyers can see what they are getting. Still, honest grading builds repeat business.

Facebook Groups & Forums

Community trust matters most. Overgrading once can damage your reputation in a group. Grade conservatively. Describe everything. People will come back to sellers they trust.

Batch Grading Worksheet

Grading a collection? Use this worksheet to track multiple records. Add rows as needed, grade each one, and print or export when done.

Artist	Title	Media Grade	Sleeve Grade	Notes	Actions

No records added yet. Click "Add Record" to start grading your batch.

Grading Glossary

Terms you will see in listings and forum discussions, explained plainly.

Surface Noise: The background hiss, crackle, or static you hear during playback. All vinyl has some. The question is how much and when it appears. Surface noise between tracks is less of a problem than noise during the music.
Hairline Scratch: A very thin, shallow scratch on the surface. Often caused by dust or a misaligned stylus. Usually not audible. A few hairline marks are normal on any played record.
Non-Fill: A pressing defect where the vinyl didn't fully fill the mold during manufacturing. It shows as a rough or frosted patch on the surface and causes repeating noise. This is not the seller's fault, but it affects the grade.
Ring Wear: A circular mark on the sleeve caused by the record pressing into the cover over time. Common on older records. Light ring wear is expected. Heavy ring wear affects the grade.
Seam Split: When the glued edge of a sleeve opens up. Measured in length. A split under 2 inches is a minor defect. A full seam split is a major one. Always mention splits in your listing.
Drill Hole: A hole punched through the sleeve (and sometimes the label) to mark a record as deleted or out of print. Common in promo and cutout stock. Always a defect. Mention it clearly.
Cut Corner: A corner of the sleeve that has been cut off to mark it as a cutout or deleted title. Same impact as a drill hole. Buyers always notice and always care.
Wow: A slow variation in pitch caused by a warp or off-center pressing. Sounds like the record briefly speeding up and slowing down. Even minor wow is a significant defect at higher grades.
Groove Wear: Wear to the record's grooves from repeated playback, especially with a worn or misaligned stylus. Causes a loss of high-frequency detail. Cannot be fixed by cleaning.
Spindle Mark: A small mark near the center hole from the turntable spindle. Normal on any played record. Not a defect unless it affects playback.

Questions Sellers Ask Most

Why This Reference Exists

Condition disputes are the single most common conflict in vinyl sales. A seller lists a record as NM. The buyer receives it and thinks it is VG+. Money gets returned. Feedback turns negative. Both sides feel cheated.

Most of these disputes happen because grading is subjective without a shared reference point. One person's VG+ is another person's VG. This grader gives you a structured process so your grades match what experienced buyers and collectors actually expect.

The disagreement notes are the key difference. For every grade, you will see exactly where buyers tend to push back. That way you can adjust your grade or add specific notes to your listing before a dispute happens.

Version 1.0. Last updated January 2026. Assumes standard stereo vinyl at 33 or 45 RPM played on a properly calibrated turntable.